TDS testing: Difference between revisions
No edit summary Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit |
m (fix broken link) |
||
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
== TDS meters == | == TDS meters == | ||
There are a variety of TDS meters available. The cheaper options tend to lack important features | There are a variety of TDS meters available. The cheaper options tend to lack important features. | ||
{| class="wikitable" | {| class="wikitable" | ||
Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
! Product | ! Product | ||
|{{Amazon|B07H578WWT|Dumsamker}} | |{{Amazon|B07H578WWT|Dumsamker}} | ||
|{{Amazon| | |{{Amazon|B09ZY2HNRR|Inkbird}} | ||
|{{Amazon|B007KDYOMU|HM AP-1}} | |{{Amazon|B007KDYOMU|HM AP-1}} | ||
|{{Amazon|B005IGXOK4|Bluelab}} | |{{Amazon|B005IGXOK4|Bluelab}} | ||
Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
|- | |- | ||
! ATC<sup>1</sup> | ! ATC<sup>1</sup> | ||
|[[File:X-mark-16.png]] | |[[File:X-mark-16.png|alt=No|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|- | |- | ||
! Calibration | ! Calibration | ||
|[[File:X-mark-16.png]] | |[[File:X-mark-16.png|alt=No|link=]] | ||
|[[File: | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|- | |- | ||
! EC display | ! EC display | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] (μS/cm) | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] (μS/cm) | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] (μS/cm) | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] (μS/cm) | ||
|[[File:X-mark-16.png]] | |[[File:X-mark-16.png|alt=No|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] (mS/cm) | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] (mS/cm) | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] (µS/cm or mS/cm) | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] (µS/cm or mS/cm) | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] (µS/cm or mS/cm) | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] (µS/cm or mS/cm) | ||
|- | |- | ||
! Backlight | ! Backlight | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:X-mark-16.png]] | |[[File:X-mark-16.png|alt=No|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:X-mark-16.png]] | |[[File:X-mark-16.png|alt=No|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|- | |- | ||
! Waterproof | ! Waterproof | ||
|[[File:X-mark-16.png]] | |[[File:X-mark-16.png|alt=No|link=]] | ||
|[[File:X-mark-16.png]] | |[[File:X-mark-16.png|alt=No|link=]] | ||
|[[File:X-mark-16.png]] | |[[File:X-mark-16.png|alt=No|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:Checkmark-16.png]] | |[[File:Checkmark-16.png|alt=Yes|link=]] | ||
|[[File:X-mark-16.png]] | |[[File:X-mark-16.png|alt=No|link=]] | ||
|- style="vertical-align: top;" | |- style="vertical-align: top;" | ||
! Notes | ! Notes | ||
| Battery is not replaceable. Dumsaker provides zero customer service; seller doesn't respond to messages. This meter is marketed under other cheapo brands as well. | | Battery is not replaceable. Dumsaker provides zero customer service; seller doesn't respond to messages. This meter is marketed under other cheapo brands as well. | ||
| | | 1-point calibration, but it resets randomly. | ||
| Digital 1-point calibration with 342 ppm NaCl. Magnetic body. | | Digital 1-point calibration with 342 ppm NaCl. Magnetic body. | ||
| Digital 1-point calibration with {{Amazon|B00Z6SJ69C|EC 2.77}} (2770 μS/cm). Displays icon for 30 days after calibration. Low battery indicator. | | Digital 1-point calibration with {{Amazon|B00Z6SJ69C|EC 2.77}} (2770 μS/cm). Displays icon for 30 days after calibration. Low battery indicator. | ||
Line 91: | Line 91: | ||
== Calibration == | == Calibration == | ||
[[File:20ppm-calibration.jpg|thumb| Reading a 20ppm test solution to verify accuracy]] | [[File:20ppm-calibration.jpg|thumb| Reading a 20ppm test solution to verify accuracy|alt=TDS meter reading 20ppm]] | ||
It's always wise to check that a measuring device is actually working as expected rather than taking the results just on faith.<ref name=ndsu/> TDS meters are known to drift and give inaccurate readings. Even if your meter isn't able to be calibrated, you can check the reading against a solution with known conductivity (a calibration solution) to verify that it is giving accurate results. Generally you should use a calibration solution with TDS near the range that you want to measure, although some meters require a specific TDS calibration fluid. | It's always wise to check that a measuring device is actually working as expected rather than taking the results just on faith.<ref name=ndsu/> TDS meters are known to drift and give inaccurate readings. Even if your meter isn't able to be calibrated, you can check the reading against a solution with known conductivity (a calibration solution) to verify that it is giving accurate results. Generally you should use a calibration solution with TDS near the range that you want to measure, although some meters require a specific TDS calibration fluid. | ||
;Buying a calibration solution | |||
Calibration solutions are available to purchase, although options are limited. Here are a few: | |||
*84 μS/cm solution available on {{Amazon|B01MR519M8}} | |||
*100 μS/cm and 1413 μS/cm solutions available on {{Amazon|B01F2OZY4U}} | |||
*700 μS/cm solution available on {{Amazon|B001VE99X8}} | |||
;Making a calibration solution | |||
You can make a calibration/testing solution yourself. For monitoring RO systems, we suggest using 18.7 mg/L NaCl (sodium chloride, table salt), which reads as 20 ppm TDS or 40 μS/cm.<ref name=forston/> | You can make a calibration/testing solution yourself. For monitoring RO systems, we suggest using 18.7 mg/L NaCl (sodium chloride, table salt), which reads as 20 ppm TDS or 40 μS/cm.<ref name=forston/> | ||
Line 127: | Line 134: | ||
| 1385 || 2770 || 142 g (for Bluelab meter) | | 1385 || 2770 || 142 g (for Bluelab meter) | ||
|} | |} | ||
== Cleaning == | == Cleaning == | ||
Line 142: | Line 143: | ||
*[[Water report]] | *[[Water report]] | ||
==References== | == References == | ||
[[Category:Quality assurance and testing]] |
Revision as of 11:31, 13 May 2024
TDS stands for Total Dissolved Solids. It's an indicator of the overall mineral content of water; it does not provide information about the individual minerals present.[1] TDS testing is mainly useful for monitoring the effectiveness of a RO purification system (whether the system is at home or in a store). It can also useful for monitoring changes in tap water because mineral levels can vary over time.[2][3][4][5] For tap water, a water report is generally required to properly adjust it for brewing since the quantities of specific minerals needs to be known. TDS is usually expressed as parts-per-million (ppm), which is practically the same as milligrams per liter (mg/L).[6]
TDS testing is conducted with a TDS meter, which is easy to use. It works indirectly: Dissolved salts (electrolytes) increase the electrical conductivity (EC) of water.[6] A TDS meter measures the EC, and then uses an equation to estimate the amount of dissolved solids.[5][6][3][7] This estimation is adequate for the purpose of monitoring a RO system, and determining whether the RO water is appropriately low in minerals to be used as a base for building a mineral profile.
TDS meters
There are a variety of TDS meters available. The cheaper options tend to lack important features.
Product | Dumsamker | Inkbird | HM AP-1 | Bluelab | Extech EC150 | Apera EC60 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
TDS range | 0-9990 ppm ±2% | 0-4995 ppm ±2% | 0-5000 ppm ±2% | 0-5000 ppm ±2% | Variable range ±1% | Variable range ±1% |
ATC1 | ||||||
Calibration | ||||||
EC display | (μS/cm) | (μS/cm) | (mS/cm) | (µS/cm or mS/cm) | (µS/cm or mS/cm) | |
Backlight | ||||||
Waterproof | ||||||
Notes | Battery is not replaceable. Dumsaker provides zero customer service; seller doesn't respond to messages. This meter is marketed under other cheapo brands as well. | 1-point calibration, but it resets randomly. | Digital 1-point calibration with 342 ppm NaCl. Magnetic body. | Digital 1-point calibration with EC 2.77 (2770 μS/cm). Displays icon for 30 days after calibration. Low battery indicator. | Digital 1-point calibration with any calibration solution. Dual-range TDS & EC, which improves accuracy (can read TDS up to 19,990). Customizable TDS conversion factor. Adjustable ATC settings. Low battery indicator. Probe requires soaking before reading if it hasn't been used in a month. | Digital calibration (up to 3-point with 1413 µS, 12.88 mS, 84 µS). The 1413 µS & 12.88 mS calibration solutions are included. Tri-range TDS & EC, which improves accuracy (can read TDS up to 10,000). Fancy platinum black conductivity sensor improves accuracy and performance. Customizable TDS conversion factor. Adjustable ATC settings. Replaceable probe. |
1 ATC is Automatic Temperature Compensation. Conductivity is affected by temperature, and meters with ATC automatically adjust the reading to provide a standardized value (25°C). If the meter does not have ATC, the sample must be at 25°C (77°F) in order to provide an accurate reading.
All of these meters also feature:
- Temperature display
- Hold function
- Automatic power-off
Inline TDS probes for monitoring input and output of RO systems exist, but there's no reason to believe they are accurate or worthwhile.
Usage
Using a TDS meter is simple:
- Let the system run for a sufficient period of time for the TDS to stabilize before taking a sample (typically around 1–2 minutes).
- Put the meter's probe into the sample, swirl gently to remove bubbles, and wait for the reading to stabilize.
- After use, rinse the probe with purified water and/or dry it with a clean cloth.
Calibration
It's always wise to check that a measuring device is actually working as expected rather than taking the results just on faith.[6] TDS meters are known to drift and give inaccurate readings. Even if your meter isn't able to be calibrated, you can check the reading against a solution with known conductivity (a calibration solution) to verify that it is giving accurate results. Generally you should use a calibration solution with TDS near the range that you want to measure, although some meters require a specific TDS calibration fluid.
- Buying a calibration solution
Calibration solutions are available to purchase, although options are limited. Here are a few:
- 84 μS/cm solution available on Amazon
- 100 μS/cm and 1413 μS/cm solutions available on Amazon
- 700 μS/cm solution available on Amazon
- Making a calibration solution
You can make a calibration/testing solution yourself. For monitoring RO systems, we suggest using 18.7 mg/L NaCl (sodium chloride, table salt), which reads as 20 ppm TDS or 40 μS/cm.[1]
- Using a high resolution scale, carefully weigh 1.87 g NaCl and add it to enough distilled water to make 1 L of a "concentrated" NaCl solution.
- Mix well to fully dissolve the salt.
- Add 10 mL of the concentrated NaCl solution to 990 mL distilled water to make a 20 ppm TDS solution. Mix well. Discard the remaining concentrated solution.
- Take a TDS reading of the solution. If the reading is reasonably close to 20 ppm or 40 μS/cm, then the device is working correctly. Otherwise, the device should be calibrated per manufacturer instructions, if possible.
- Note: If the meter does not have ATC, the sample must be at 25°C (77°F).
The calibration solution can be stored in a sealed container for later use.
You can follow the same instructions above, but with a different amount of salt to make a calibration solution with a TDS tailored to your needs:
TDS | μS/cm | NaCl to make concentrate solution |
---|---|---|
20 | 40 | 1.87 g |
42 | 84 | 4.00 g (for Apera EC60 meter) |
50 | 100 | 4.74 g |
100 | 200 | 9.52 g |
200 | 400 | 19.2 g |
351 | 701 | 34.2 g (for HM AP-1 meter) |
500 | 1000 | 49.1 g |
1385 | 2770 | 142 g (for Bluelab meter) |
Cleaning
If the probe surface is dirty, soak it in water with a mild detergent (e.g. dish soap) for 15 minutes. Then soak it in a dilute acid solution (such as citric acid or acetic acid) for another 15 minutes. Then rinse it well with distilled water.[1] This process removes both organic and inorganic (mineral) residue. See Cleaning for more information.
See also
References
- ↑ a b c d Conductivity probe. Forston Labs. 2010.
- ↑ Briggs DE, Boulton CA, Brookes PA, Stevens R. Brewing Science and Practice. Woodhead Publishing Limited and CRC Press LLC; 2004.
- ↑ a b Palmer J, Kaminski C. Water: A Comprehensive Guide for Brewers. Brewers Publications; 2013.
- ↑ Taylor DG. Water. In: Stewart GG, Russell I, Anstruther A, eds. Handbook of Brewing. 3rd ed. CRC Press; 2017.
- ↑ a b Brungard M. TDS meter: Do you need one? Bru'n Water website. Accessed May 2022.
- ↑ a b c d e Using electrical conductivity and total dissolved solids meters to field test water quality. North Dakota State University website. 2019. Accessed May 2022.
- ↑ Feminella V. Pure brewing water using reverse osmosis. The Screwy Brewer website. 2014. Accessed May 2022.
- ↑ FAQ. Buckeye Hydro website. Accessed May 2022.